Suburb · 470 residents
Good · better than 6 in 10 suburbs
Check Local Score out of 100 · 60 is typical for the country
Each arc is a topic, coloured by its score
Map outline: Approximate — no official boundary exists for this neighbourhood
Modenhill scores 61/100 overall, which the scorecard rates as good — 60 is typical for the country.
It stands out for affordability (70).
It scores lowest on food & drink (27).
Scores come from official data on safety, schools, transport, prices, health, food & drink and the local environment, for Modenhill in West Midlands, each measured against the national average.
Modenhill reads as settled, semi-detached Dudley – pebble-dashed frontages, hedges kept neat, and a resident base that skews well past its 30s. With a median age of 54, this isn't a street of young families jostling for school places; it's a place where people tend to have arrived some years ago and stayed.
The housing stock backs that up: semi-detached homes dominate the sales sample, nearly all freehold, with a median price around £265,000. That's above what you'd pay in Dudley itself — about 18% higher than the borough median — and sits close to the middle of the pack nationally, comfortable rather than aspirational. A decile 8 for deprivation puts Modenhill among the less deprived parts of the country, even though the income picture is more middling, right around the national average. For schools, St Chad's Catholic Primary carries a Good rating and Cotwall End Primary anchors the other end of the area, though its Ofsted grading isn't listed here — worth checking directly if a place there matters to you. There's no rail station named in the data, and the transport grade sits at a C, noticeably behind the B+ grades that colour most of Modenhill's other scores — if you don't drive, that's the one figure to sit with before anything else.
Green space and connectivity fare better: full fibre reaches 88% of the area, useful if you work from home, and the environment grade holds at a solid B. The crime picture is where the local comparison matters most — violence and sexual offences make up 43% of the 31 incidents logged in the past year, and against Dudley's own crime rate, Modenhill's is running markedly higher, even as the borough-wide safety grade for the area itself lands at B+ and the trend is flat rather than worsening. That contrast — a reassuring letter grade sitting above a rate that's well up on the parent area — is worth noticing rather than skating past. Health is graded B, in line with a population that's ageing in place, and the nightlife grade (C+) tells you this isn't a place built around evening life; it's quieter, more domestic in rhythm.
Put together, Modenhill suits someone who wants a freehold semi in a stable, low-turnover pocket of Dudley, is comfortable driving rather than relying on rail, and isn't chasing school catchments or a lively high street. The trade-off worth sitting with is that flat safety trend against a crime rate meaningfully above the wider borough — not alarming on its own, but the one figure that doesn't quite match the calm, settled feel of the streets themselves.
Data last updated: 19 October 2026
Pick another area to line them up side by side — the verdict, both Check Local Scores, and what actually separates them.