Alstonefield in West Midlands has a Check Local Score of 67/100 (good), drawn from official data on safety, schools, transport, housing, amenities and the local environment, each measured against the national average — a score of 60 is typical for the country.
Alstonefield reads exactly as you'd expect from a Peak District-edge village: stone cottages, dry-stone walling, cars parked on verges because there's nowhere else to put them, and a population you could fit into a couple of large office floors. This is not a place with a high street of chain shops or a bustling centre — it's scattered, quiet, and built for people who already know they want space over convenience.
The numbers back up the visual. A median age pushing 52 against a national figure of 40 tells you this is a village of settled households rather than young families chasing their first step onto the ladder, and with a population density a fraction of the regional average, that's no surprise. Housing here is overwhelmingly freehold, semi-detached or a mix of "other" rural stock, and every sale in the local sample was freehold — the kind of For Sale board that says "old house, no chain, no leasehold small print" rather than new-build estate. Prices sit noticeably above the immediate district: a median around £277k is roughly a quarter higher than the Staffordshire Moorlands parent figure, though still below the steep upper reaches of the national market, so you're paying a premium for the setting rather than buying into an expensive region outright. Council tax band D near £195 is unusually low next to the national median of near £1,400, which is worth checking rather than assuming — but as recorded, it's a real point in the village's favour.
Schooling is thin on the ground by design — this is a village, not a town — but Ilam Church of England Primary School carries a Good Ofsted rating, and Waterhouses CofE Primary Academy serves the same rural catchment; neither will suit a family wanting a big secondary nearby, and there's no rail station in the picture at all, so a car is not optional here, it's the whole infrastructure. Broadband tells a similar story of partial modernity: full-fibre coverage sits around 63%, decent for a village this size but not universal, so working from home is realistic rather than guaranteed everywhere.
Green space is modest in raw hectares but Alstonefield's real outdoor life is the Peak District landscape around it rather than a fenced-off park — walking, dry-stone-wall country, pub lunches rather than restaurant rows. Crime is low in absolute terms, just 15 incidents across the year, and the safety grade sits at the top of the national scale with the trend holding flat, though violence and sexual offences make up the largest single share of what does occur — worth knowing, not worth dwelling on, given how small the underlying numbers are. Health and environment grades sit comfortably mid-to-upper table, nightlife scores respectably for somewhere this size (which likely means a good pub rather than options plural), and transport and affordability grades top out high, which will surprise people who assume rural means expensive — here it means older, quieter, and unusually good value against national and even regional benchmarks. This suits people who've already decided they want stone walls over street lighting, a car over a station, and a settled, older community over a young, transient one; anyone needing schools clustered nearby or fibre broadband guaranteed on day one should look elsewhere first.
Data last updated: 15 August 2026
Pick another area to line them up side by side — the verdict, both Check Local Scores, and what actually separates them.